Civilization, Drawbacks and Limitations

Civilization: Drawbacks And Limits

The Rise Of Civilization In The Middle East And Africa

Because civilizations are by definition well organized compared to the

societies that preceded them, it is not surprising that almost all history is

about what has happened to civilized societies. We know most about such

societies, and we are likely to be particularly impressed by their great art

or powerful rulers. It is also true that civilizations tended to be far more

populous than noncivilized societies. Because civilizations depend on some

trade, they allow greater specialization that increases productivity and

sustenance of larger populations. Their political structure allows whole

regions or even a number of regions to be unified. But the history of

civilization does not embrace everybody. In the days of the river-valley

civilizations, even long after Sumer, most inhabited parts of the world were

not in the civilization orbit.

There is inevitable confusion between defining a society as a

civilization and assuming that civilization produces a monopoly on higher

values and controlled behavior. In the first place, civilization brings losses

as well as gains. As the Middle East moved toward civilization, distinctions

based on social class and wealth increased. This was clearly the case in

Sumer, where social structure ranged from slaves, who were treated as

property, to powerful kings and priests. Civilizations typically have firmer

class or caste divisions and greater separations between ruler and ruled than

"simpler" societies. Civilizations also often create greater inequality

between men and women than noncivilized societies do. Many early

civilizations, including those of the Middle East, went to considerable pains

to organize the inferiority of women on a more structured basis than ever

before, treating women as the property of fathers or husbands. Finally, as

Sigmund Freud noted, civilizations impose a host of restraints on people in

order to keep them organized in a complex social unit. Such restraints can

create a great deal of personal tension and even mental illness.

"Civilization," then, should not be taken as a synonym for "a `good' or

`progressive' society."

Furthermore, people in noncivilized societies may be exceptionally well

regulated and possessed of interesting, important culture. They are not

"merely" barbarians or uncouth wild men. Some societies that were most eager

to repress anger and aggression in human dealings, such as several Eskimo

groups, were not part of a civilization until recently. In contrast, many

civilized societies produce a great deal of aggressive behavior and build

warlike qualities into their list of virtues. While some noncivilized

societies treat old people cruelly, others display respect and veneration. A

civilized society does not invariably enhance the human capacity for

restrained, polite behavior or an interest in the higher values of life.

Civilizations do not even clearly promote greater human happiness.

The development of civilization continued the process of enhancing human

capacity for technological and political organization, and the production of

increasingly elaborate and diverse artistic and intellectual forms. In this

quite restricted sense, the term has meaning and legitimately commands the

attention of most historians. Because of the power and splendor civilizations

could provide, they did tend to spread as other societies came under their

influence or deliberately tried to imitate their achievements. Early

civilizations, however, spread slowly because many peoples had no contact with

them and because their disadvantages, such as greater social inequality, might

be repellent. Thus the initial advent of civilization, while an important

historical milestone, came in clearly circumscribed regions like the

Tigris-Euphrates valley. The history of early civilization focuses attention

on the generation of the first forms of civilized activity - writing and city

administration - and on the construction of linkages in medium-sized

geographical units.

The Course Of Mesopotamian Civilization: A Series Of Conquests

The general characteristics of civilization, from economic surplus to

writing, cities, and social inequality, are vital, but must be combined with

the specific qualities of particular civilizations such as those of

Mesopotamia, where writing was of a certain style; social organization was

distinctive, for example, in the power of priests; and overall culture had

some special qualities.

A key ingredient of Mesopotamian civilization was frequent instability as

one ruling people gave way to another invading force. The Sumerians,

themselves invaders of the fertile river valleys, did not set up a

sufficiently strong and united political force to withstand pressures from

outside, particularly when other peoples of the Middle East began to copy key

achievements, such as the formation of cities.

Later Mesopotamian Empires

Shortly after 2400 B.C. a king from a non-Sumerian city, Akkad, conquered

the Sumerian city-states and inaugurated an Akkadian Empire. This empire soon

sent troops as far as Egypt and Ethiopia. The initial Akkadian ruler, Sargon

I, the first clearly identified individual in world history, set up a unified

empire integrating the city-states into a whole, and added to Sumerian art a

new style marked by the theme of royal victory. Professional military

organization expanded since Sargon maintained a force of 5400 troops.

Extensive tax revenues were needed to support his operations. The Akkadians

were the first people to use writing for more than commercial and temple

records, producing a number of literary works. The Akkadian empire, however,

lasted only about 200 years, and then it was overthrown by another invading

force. Sumerian regional states reappeared, in what turned out to be the final

phase of this particular civilization. It was then that the Epic of Gilgamesh

was written. By this time, around 2000 B.C., kingdoms were springing up in

various parts of the Middle East, while new invading groups, including Indo-

European tribes that came from the Balkans in southeastern Europe, added to

the region's confusion. A civilization derived from Sumerian culture spread

more widely in the Middle East, though political unity was rarely achieved in

the expanded setting.

Another new empire arose around 1800 B.C., for the first time unifying

the whole of Mesopotamia. This Babylonian Empire was headed by Hammurabi, one

of the great rulers of early civilized history. Hammurabi set up an extensive

network of officials and judges, while maintaining a separate priesthood. He

also codified the laws of the region, to deal with a number of criminal,

property, and family issues. Large cities testified to the wealth and power of

this new empire. At the same time, Sumerian cultural traditions were

maintained and elaborated. The famous Hammurabic code thus was built on

earlier codifications by Sumerian kings.

A Babylonian poem testified to the continued sobriety of the dominant

culture: "I look about me and see only evil. My troubles grow and I cannot

find justice. I have prayed to the gods and sacrificed, but who can understand

the gods in heaven? Who knows what they plan for us? Who has ever been able to

understand a god's conduct?"

Finally, Babylonian scientists extended the Sumerian work in astronomy

and mathematics. Scholars were able to predict lunar eclipses and trace the

paths of some of the planets. Babylonians also worked out mathematical tables

and an algebraic geometry of great practical utility. The modern 60-minute

hour and 360-degree circle are heritages of the Babylonian system of

measurement. The study of astronogy is another Babylonian legacy.

Indeed, of all the successors of the Sumerians, the Babylonians

constructed the most elaborate culture, though their rule was not long-lived.

The Babylonians expanded commerce and a common cultural zone, both based on

growing use of cuneiform writing and a shared language. During the empire

itself, new government strength showed both in the extensive legal system and

in the opulent public buildings and royal palaces. The hanging gardens of one

king dazzled visitors from the entire region.

The Babylonian empire fell by about 1600 B.C. An invading Hittite people,

pressing in from central Asia, adapted the Sumerian cuneiform script to their

own Indo-European language and set up an empire of their own. The Hittites

soon yielded, and a series of smaller kingdoms disputed the region for several

centuries, between about 1200 and 900 B.C. This period allowed a number of

regional cultures, such as the Hebrew and the Phoenician, to develop greater

autonomy, thus adding to the diversity and the achievements of the Middle

East. Then, after about 900 B.C., another series of empires began in the

Middle East, including the Assyrian Empire and later the Persian Empire based

on invasions of new groups from central Asia. These new invaders had mastered

the production of iron weapons and also used horses and chariots in fighting,

sketching a new framework for the development of empires and a new chapter in

the history of the Middle East and of civilization more generally.

[See Head Of Sargon: This bronze head of Sargon, founder of the Akkadian

dynasty, dates from about 2350 B.C. The elaborate metalwork displays the

artistic talent acquired by leading craftsmen.]

Document: Hammurabi's Law Code

Hammurabi, as king of Babylon, united Mesopotamia under his rule from

about 1800 to 1750 B.C. His law code, the earliest such compilation still in

existence, was discovered on a stone slab in Iran in A.D. 1901. Not a

systematic presentation, it was a collection of exemplary cases designed to

set general standards of justice. The code provides vital insights into the

nature of social relations and family structure in this ancient civilization.

Examples of the Hammurabic code follow:

When Marduk commanded me to give justice to the people of the land and to

let [them] have [good] governance, I set forth truth and justice throughout

the land [and] prospered the people.

At that time:

If a man has accused a man and has charged him with manslaughter and then has

not proved [it against] him, his accuser shall be put to death.

If a man has charged a man with sorcery and then has not proved [it against]

him, he who is charged with the sorcery shall go to the holy river; he shall

leap into the holy river and, if the holy river overwhelms him, his accuser

shall take and keep his house; if the holy river proves that man clear [of the

offense] and he comes back safe, he who has charged him with sorcery shall be

put to death; he who leapt into the holy river shall take and keep the house

of his accuser.

If a man has come forward in a case to bear witness to a felony and then has

not proved the statement that he has made, if that case [is] a capital one,

that man shall be put to death.

If he has come forward to bear witness to [a claim for] corn or money, he

shall remain liable for the penalty for that suit.

If a judge has tried a suit, given a decision, caused a sealed tablet to be

executed, [and] thereafter varies his judgment, they shall convict that judge

of varying [his] judgment and he shall pay twelve-fold the claim in that suit;

then they shall remove him from his place on the bench of judges in the

assembly, and he shall not [again] sit in judgment with the judges.

If a free person helps a slave to escape, the free person will be put to


If a man has committed robbery and is caught, that man shall be put to death.

If the robber is not caught, the man who has been robbed shall formally

declare whatever he has lost before a god, and the city and the mayor in whose

territory or district the robbery has been committed shall replace whatever he

has lost for him.

If [it is] the life [of the owner that is lost], the city or the mayor shall

pay one maneh of silver to his kinsfolk.

If a person owes money and Adad [the river god] has flooded the person's

field, the person will not give any grain [tax] or pay any interest in that


If a person is too lazy to make the dike of his field strong and there is a

break in the dike and water destroys his own farmland, that person will make

good the grain [tax] that is destroyed.

If a merchant increases interest beyond that set by the king and collects it,

that merchant will lose what was lent.

If a trader borrows money from a merchant and then denies the fact, that

merchant in the presence of god and witnesses will prove the trader borrowed

the money and the trader will pay the merchant three times the amount


If the husband of a married lady has accused her but she is not caught lying

with another man, she shall take an oath by the life of a god and return to

her house.

If a man takes himself off and there is not the [necessary] maintenance in his

house, his wife [so long as] her [husband is delayed], shall keep [herself

chaste; she shall not] enter [another man's house].

If that woman has not kept herself chaste but enters another man's house, they

shall convict that woman and cast her into the water.

If a son strikes his father, they shall cut off his forehand.

If a man has put out the eye of a free man, they shall put out his eye.

If he breaks the bone of a [free] man, they shall break his bone.

If he puts out the eye of a villain or breaks the bone of a villain, he shall

pay 1 maneh of silver.

If he puts out the eye of a [free] man's slave or breaks the bone of a [free]

man's slave, he shall pay half his price.

If a man knocks out the tooth of a [free] man equal [in rank] to him[self],

they shall knock out his tooth.

If he knocks out the tooth of a villain, he shall pay 1/3 maneh of silver.

If a man strikes the cheek of a [free] man who is superior [in rank] to

him[self], he shall be beaten with 60 stripes with a whip of ox-hide in the


If the man strikes the cheek of a free man equal to him[self in rank], he

shall pay 1 maneh of silver.

If a villain strikes the cheek of a villain, he shall pay 10 shekels of


If the slave of a [free] man strikes the cheek of a free man, they shall cut

off his ear.

You Might Also Like:

World History related image
Read More

World History

Welcome to our World History section, a vast treasure trove of historical knowledge that takes you on a captivating journey through the annals of human civilization. Our collection spans a wide spectrum of topics, providing an exhaustive resource for history enthusiasts, students, and curious minds ...
Read More

A Complete History Of The European Middle Ages

The Middle Ages Date: 1992 During the decline of the Roman Empire, the migrations of a strong, rude people began to change the life of Europe. They were the German barbarians, or Teutonic tribes, who swept across the Rhine and the Danube into the empire. There they accepted Christianity. The union o...
Read More

A Day In The Life Of A Battle Of Britain Pilot

The following would have been a typical day in the life of a Battle of Britain pilot The sequences are based on the works of different authors with the exception that the names have been changed. This is just to give you an idea as to how a pilot may have spent his day at the height of the battle. ...
Read More

A General Survey Of The Slave Plantation

The American Civil War, Frederick Douglass Edited by: Robert Guisepi 2002 A General Survey of the Slave Plantation by Frederick Douglass It was generally supposed that slavery in the State of Maryland existed in its mildest form, and that it was totally divested of those harsh and terrible peculiari...
Read More

A. P. Hill

The American Civil War, A. P. Hill Edited by: Robert Guisepi 2002 b. Nov. 9, 1825, Culpeper, Va., U.S.d. April 2, 1865, Petersburg, Va. Confederate general during the U.S. Civil War who was particularly active in the fighting around Washington, D.C. His force, called the "Light Division," was cons...
Read More


The American Civil War, Abolition, The Movement Edited by: Robert Guisepi 2002 There can be no doubt that antislavery, or "abolition" as it came to be called, was the nonpareil reform. Abolition was a diverse phenomenon. At one end of its spectrum was William Lloyd Garrison, an "immediatist," who de...
Read More

Abraham Lincoln

The American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln American Civil War history with slideshows, photos, music, major battles like Gettysburg as well as personalities like Lincoln, Grant, Lee and the Black Regiments Edited by: Robert Guisepi 2002 He was an unusual man in many ways. One minute he would wrestle wi...
Read More


European Absolutism And Power Politics Introduction Louis XIV (1643-1715) of France is remembered best as a strong-willed monarch who reportedly once exclaimed to his fawning courtiers, "L'etat, c'est moi" (I am the state). Whether or not he really said these words, Louis has been regarded by histor...
Read More

Absolutism As A System

Absolutism As A System L'Etat, C'Est Moi Date: 1998 Absolutism As A System Unlimited royal authority, as advocated by Bossuet and Hobbes, was the main characteristic of absolutism. It was demonstrated most obviously in political organization but also served to integrate into government most econom...
Read More

Absolutism, Case Against

The Case Against AbsolutismAuthor: Wallbank;Taylor;Bailkey;Jewsbury;Lewis;HackettDate: 1992The Case Against AbsolutismThe Enlightenment's highest achievement was the development of a tightlyorganized philosophy, purportedly based on scientific principles andcontradicting every argument for absolute ...
Read More

Accession Of Solomon

Accession Of Solomon Author: Milman, Henry Hart Accession Of Solomon B.C. 1017 Introduction After many weary years of travail and fighting in the wilderness and the land of Canaan, the Jews had at last founded their kingdom, with Jerusalem as the capital. Saul was proclaimed the first king; afterwa ...
Read More


A History of Ancient Greece The Glory That Was Greece Author: Jewsbury, Lewis Date: 1992 The Acropolis Acropolis (Greek akros,"highest"; polis,"city"), term originally applied to any fortified natural stronghold or citadel in ancient Greece. Primarily a place of refuge, the typical acropolis was con...
Read More

Aegean Civilization

A History of Ancient Greece Author: Robert Guisepi Date: 1998 AEGEAN CIVILIZATION The earliest civilization in Europe appeared on the coasts and islands of the Aegean Sea. This body of water is a branch of the Mediterranean Sea. It is bounded by the Greek mainland on the west, Asia Minor (now Turkey...
Read More

Aemilius Paulus

AEMILIUS PAULUS by Plutarch Almost all historians agree that the Aemilii were one of the ancient and patrician houses in Rome; and those authors who affirm that king Numa was pupil to Pythagoras, tell us that the first who gave the name to his posterity was Mamercus, the son of Pythagoras, who, for ...
Read More

Africa In The Age Of The Slave Trade

Africa And The Africans In The Age Of The Atlantic Slave Trade Various Authors Edited By: R. A. GuisepiAfrican Societies, Slavery, And The Slave TradeEuropeans in the age of the slave trade sometimes justified enslavementof Africans by pointing out that slavery already existed on that continent.Howe...
Read More